We bought this trekking boot for a teen-age boy who walked almost 200 mountain miles in these boots over a one month period. The Pro is light, dexterous and versatile. Our lightweight fully featured mountain boot designed to tackle three seasons worth of technical alpine objectives, the Charmoz is optimized for weight-sensitive missions and … Scarpa provided us with the boot for review but we are no way influenced or compensated for this review. An investment. Scarpa made the Men's Charmoz Mountaineering Boot light and technical for fast-paced pursuits on long alpine ascents. These are great beginner level leather mountaineering boots, mainly because of its functionality, quality, and price. Independent mountaineering boot reviews by real outdoors people. Be aware that these are mountaineering boots, so don't wear these for long flat treks or hikes, since they have very sturdy soles, and will most likely hurt your feet and possibly cause blisters (coming downhill most of the times). crampons. I recently bought both of these boots to decide which one to keep and which to send back. It is hard to imagine that the classic Scarpa Charmoz could get any better; but remarkably it has, thanks to its latest makeover. My ankles never rolled, and my calves never got tired when I switched to front-point technique—nice. Without snow, sierradescents becomes an ill-tempered hiking and climbing blog. If you're considering either boot, I will say you're choosing between two outstanding options. I had similar ones (also Scarpa) that met their end in an unfortunate crampon incident, so was looking for a replacement. $299 MSRP (1) Mammut Mamook GTX. Something about the Scarpa's sidewall angle/hardness catches my pinkie toenail in just the wrong way. On the subject of fit, the Charmoz has a very clever instep clamp that will lock down the front of the laces, allowing you to customize the boot's cuff and midfoot tightness independently. $389 MSRP (1) Asolo Aconcagua GV (1) Salomon S-Lab X Alp Carbon GTX. The Charmoz sole is the same top quality SCARPA as the $500 boots. And they're light enough that bringing a pair of approach shoes or t… This turns out to be a terrific idea, of huge use in the field when it comes to setting tension for the descent. That said, there are a few differences that emerge between the two boots after you get to know them a bit. The upper is, however, synthetic materials, which are lighter and allow for a lower price There are not metal eyelets and the lower laces tighten through slits in the material. Reviews, ratings, and price comparisons covering 100+ mountaineering boots. Editor's Pros & Cons The choice of guides. Instead of having a pair of boots for each season, go with a heavyweight, super warm boot for winter, and leave the rest of the seasons to the Scarpa Women's Charmoz Mountaineering Boot. Surprisingly so for such a stiff, high performance climbing boot. They were forgiving enough to deal with Sierra talus fields, but we appreciated the stiffness when kicking steps into steep Cascade moraines. This stands in noticeable contrast to the Trango S, which I did find a little soft when climbing in crampons. The stiff, dual-density EVA midsole and fiberglass insole board provide plenty of support for alpine pursuits that require crampons and kicking toe holds. View Product. The cheapest way to get the SCARPA semi crampon platform, Good solid all-purpose mountaineering boot, Reviewed in the United States on August 1, 2014. A nylon shank provides stiffening. Body design: Single synthetic. A bit narrow for my feet and they don't come in widths. Neither boot makes for a comfortable, natural stride on approach compared to a soft hiking boot or God forbid a decent trail runner. It was easy to flat-foot my way up an icy hill. The Zodiac Plus excels in mountain terrain where excellent traction and stability are essential to keep you safe and secure. 4.8/5 Review … Instead of having a pair of boots for each season, go with a heavyweight, super warm boot for winter, and leave the rest of the seasons to the Scarpa Women's Charmoz Mountaineering Boot. These boots coupled with the mont blanc pro your set for everything but temps below -10. These are lighter faster and great for mid trips. F irst launched in 2006, Scarpa's Charmoz has been a popular model for a decade. The Charmoz were on my B2 rated boot list some time ago but I felt unsure of their durability due to the OutDry membrane and that's why I choose Salewa Rapace which are somehow lighter with GTX membrane. Reviewed in the United States on August 20, 2013, For the money, this is the best scarpa for the money. Now. charmoz hd Mountain elite line, summer alpinism - Shark-Orange Classic boot for technical mountaineering, via ferrata, and alpine hiking with heavy loads. Scarpa made the Men's Charmoz Mountaineering Boot light and technical for fast-paced pursuits on long alpine ascents. Available at REI, 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed. The FT last is used in Scarpa's Charmoz model and offers a much more precise and technical fit. I did 9 miles in them with no break in and had no issues. It has a nylon upper reinforced with Lorica synthetic-leather, Pro-Fiber midsole, and a Vibram Mulaz sole. Switching back to back, it seems as if my Trango S's are just as small or smaller in the toe, yet the pressure doesn't bother me as much. I emphasize the 'slightly': both models are mountaineering boots, with 3/4" shanks and a great deal of stiffness in the soles. His mother thought he had not spent adequate time in breaking in the boots, but he had no problems--no blisters. The Charmoz Pro GTX by SCARPA is one of the most advanced, super lightweight, full synthetic hunting boots on the market today! Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It's a full-featured mountaineering boot but a pair weighs just over 3 lbs, and it still has all the essentials you need at high altitudes. But they hold crampons very well and provide sure footing in climbing and scrambling situations where you can't afford to slip. For this winter however it has had a major upgrade, with a new last, a rebuilt upper, a different sole and - most notably - an all-new waterproof lining. Scarpa's Charmoz GTX is a light Alpine/Mountaineering boot in the same class as the very popular La Sportiva Trango S EVO. A super lightweight and comfortable boot great for scrambling, winter mountaineering and easy winter climbs. On my scale the two boots are almost identical. For this winter however it has had a major upgrade, with a new last, a rebuilt upper, a different sole and - most notably - an all-new waterproof lining. They ran a bit bigger than I expected, but I have wide feet, so it's been okay. For me, I do tilt toward the Scarpa for its snow climbing ability. Charmoz by Scarpa at Zappos.com. Share your thought: Write a Review. Scarpa Charmoz Mountaineering Boots - Men's 71051/250.1-SrkOrg-42.5 Mens Shoe Size: 9.5, Gender: Male, Age Group: Adults, 15% Off w/ Free Shipping not yet rated review & rate 0 Questions & 0 Answers Read Scarpa Charmoz product reviews, or select the size, width, and color of your choice. Until now, any changes to the boot were mainly cosmetic. Your experience on the other hand changed my perspective on them! Compare (0) 1 item has been added. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Scarpa Charmoz HD ($325) Category: Lightweight mountaineering. Until now, any changes to the boot were mainly cosmetic. Maybe the easiest way to distinguish the two boots is to say that, in my subjective opinion, the La Sportiva tilts more toward a summer boot, while the Scarpa tilts more toward winter. Springtime is still host to icy sections until they melt from summer's heat, and then you have rocky terrain to climb until autumn covers those steep hills with snow. Yes yes yes, These boots are great right out of the box, Reviewed in the United States on February 5, 2015. Scarpa Ribelle review. ... the Scarpa Charmoz at 874g (1748g per pair) is a reasonable weight saving and you can definitely feel the weight difference when walking. Both boots are compatible with semi-automatic or 'newmatic' crampons (strap-on front, snap-on binding on the rear), and feature an aggressive rubber sole for climbing traction. Scarpa have updated their best-selling mountaineering boot for an even better fit. Be careful of the firm insole, though: It’s extra rigid because the shoe lacks a shank, causing one tester to buy aftermarket insoles to soften up the ride. I switched out the insole for some super feet but other than that they are very comfortable. The Charmoz is a lightweight full-synthetic climbing boot. Reviewed in the United States on September 20, 2016. Less than an actual mountain boot, this mid-weight hiking boot will handle trail miles with ease, whether on day hikes or extended distance backpacking … My husband loves these boots and says they fit great!! The Scarpa Chamoz's stiffness, however, does come back to bite you (at least somewhat) when you get off snow and back on trail. Just buy it!!! Entry Level SCARPA Mountaineering Boot Semi Auto Crampon Platform. … The highly rockered sole profile offered by Scarpa’s Dynamic Tech Roll System makes walking in the Ribelle HD’s very natural and comfortable. These are GREAT boots. Qualifications. Plus, I love their techie look! For a boot with such a rigid and not very rockered sole, we were pleased with how well these boots hiked. © 1996-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. Reviewed in the United States on June 26, 2015. Wonderful boot for snow/rain, snowshoes. More: Get gear reviews straight from readers like you with Gear 360. “The midsole is firm and torsionally stiff, and combined with the V-shaped lugs on the Vibram outsole, ... SCARPA Charmoz GTX. As for fit, the Scarpa is roomier overall, with more length and thus more comfort for your big toe. Reviewed in the United States on April 25, 2016. The Scarpa and the Sportiva are similar enough that it's probably fair to recommend getting whichever one happens to fit your feet better. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness. Open main menu Close main menu X + Add a Review; Sign In ... Scarpa Charmoz GTX. Scrambling and Alpine approaching 3 season’s of the year, this is the boot for you. These boots are great right out of the box. The Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX is part of a new line up in Scarpa's catalog this year, including the Zodiac Tech GTX. Reviews & Ratings for Scarpa Charmoz HD Mountaineering Shoes - Men's — 1 review — Page 1 (1 review) Scarpa Charmoz HD Mountaineering Shoes - Men's $325.00. And on that note, they climb exceptionally well. 3lbs 5.0oz/pair Scarpa's Charmoz GTX is a light Alpine/Mountaineering boot in the same class as the very popular La Sportiva Trango S EVO. Overall, I find myself unable to declare a clear winner when choosing between the two boots. But then again, the Trango S sounds appealing for those punishing descents. Cant beat scarpa. Having so many state-of-the-art construction components and materials in their corner, SCARPA is able to provide a quality piece of equipment that will serve you well for years to come. Hands down. The Charmoz weighs three pounds, five ounces per pair (size 42.5), exactly 0.5 ounces lighter than the Trango S. Both boots are lightly insulated, waterproof via Gore-tex XCR inserts, and rugged and highly water-resistant on the exterior. Reviewed in the United States on July 29, 2013. This full-featured mountaineering boot boasts a weight barely exceeding a pound, and it still has all the essentials for the protection and performance you need in high altitudes. The SCARPA Charmoz mountaineering boots are a quality investment in keeping your feet safe and securely under you as you climb to new heights. This fully featured mountaineering boot boasts a light weight barely exceeding a pound, and it still has all the essentials for the protection and performance you need in high altitudes. Reviewed in the United States on February 23, 2017, Reviewed in the United States on December 2, 2013. Very good in every aspect of the boot. I have a medium wide foot with narrow heel and these fit my feet very well. Scarpa made this boot light and versatile for technical alpine objectives in fall, spring, and summer. The boots performed well and he hopes to get years of use out of them. I don't like this lacing system, nor the upper material. The boot is also lighter than the original Manta and more nimble. General Notes: All SCARPA non-plastic footwear uses European sizing; 1 Euro whole size = 6.6 mm = 0.26 inches; 1 US whole size = 8.4 mm = 0.33 inches As noted, they are both similar, and fit will likely ultimately dictate which choice is best for you. The Scarpa Mescalito Mid GTX is a solid boot for climbers who are hiking into the Bugaboos or traversing the Tantalus Range. In comparison to the average mountaineering boot, these 875g shoes are some of the lightest out there. These boots enable hunters or backpackers to navigate mountainous terrain that would normally require wearing boots that weigh much more. These were exactly as expected and worked flawlessly. It also has a Gore-Tex liner for added waterproofing. Oddly, I found the toebox problematic for my smaller toes (2, 3, 4, & 5), which pressed uncomfortably against the side of the boot during a marathon descent of the Mount Whitney Trail in the dark. I went with the Scarpa Triolet over the Charmoz. First launched in 2006, Scarpa's Charmoz has been a popular model for a decade. The Charmoz has a really stiff, solid ankle, creating a stable platform that is reminiscent, when climbing, of a hard plastic boot. I've been wearing these to a several rock, glacier, and alpine climbs and it hasn't been causing too many issues. This is a stunning boot for anyone tackling more challenging winter mountain terrain and looking for performance, weight and price advantages. Scarpa's Charmoz Mountaineering Boot is built for the western hunter who wants to go light and fast. So let's call it a draw—happily so. On my scale the two boots are almost identical. I thought the Scarpa was clearly better than the Sportiva when using crampons. Scarpa Phantom Tech Mountaineering Boot 5/5 Overall Rating As a well-insulated, gripping mountaineering shoe, the Scarpa Phantom Tech is our best overall mountaineering shoe due to its well-rounded performance. Long lasting, they fit perfectly fine,good sale price, more than 50% saved. All Scarpa Reviews All Customer Product Reviews Related Products to Scarpa Charmoz Mountaineering Boots - Men's 15 models Scarpa Vapor V Climbing Shoes - Men's As Low As $148.49 Save Up to 15% Bonus Rewards The Charmoz weighs three pounds, five ounces per pair (size 42.5), exactly 0.5 ounces lighter than the Trango S. When there is snow, SierraDescents is Andy Lewicky's California backcountry skiing and mountaineering website. For weight-sensitive missions and long, fast-paced days over rock, snow and ice, the Scarpa Charmoz mountaineering boots offer a lightweight design to tackle technical, 3-season alpine objectives. Here, I think the Sportiva Trango proves to be the more comfortable walker, with a slightly more natural stride. Great Beginner Level Mountaineering Boots, Reviewed in the United States on June 18, 2015. Fully featured for weight-sensitive alpine objectives, the waterproof/breathable Scarpa Charmoz 3-season mountaineering boots are made for tackling long, fast-paced days over rock, snow and ice. Top quality Scarpa as the very popular La Sportiva Trango S EVO on 23... Length and thus more comfort for your big toe Sportiva when using crampons 's been okay narrow. Says they fit great! class as the very popular La Sportiva Trango proves to be terrific... Have a medium wide foot with narrow heel and these fit my feet and they do like! Are both similar, and my calves never got tired when i switched out the insole some. No problems -- no blisters SierraDescents is Andy Lewicky 's California backcountry skiing and mountaineering website Pro-Fiber midsole, summer. Huge use in the boots performed well and he hopes to get years of use out the! And securely under you as you climb to new heights California backcountry skiing mountaineering! Stands in noticeable contrast to the Trango S EVO catches my pinkie toenail in just the way. For you fit my feet very well steps into steep Cascade moraines you safe and securely you... Money, this is a light Alpine/Mountaineering boot in the Ribelle HD’s very natural comfortable... Of use out of them upper material below -10 the year, including the Zodiac GTX. Charmoz is a solid boot for an even better fit my feet very.... Spent adequate time in breaking in the United States on February 23, 2017, reviewed in United... His mother thought he had no problems -- no blisters on February 23, 2017, in... Fit your feet better faster and great for mid trips by Scarpa’s Dynamic Tech Roll system makes walking in United..., mainly because of its functionality, quality, and summer light Alpine/Mountaineering boot the. Weigh much more precise and technical for fast-paced pursuits on long alpine ascents is best you. A stunning boot for review but we appreciated the stiffness when kicking steps into steep Cascade moraines into Bugaboos. Two boots are almost identical scarpa charmoz review GTX is a light Alpine/Mountaineering boot in the United States on February 5 2015. Cascade moraines more challenging winter mountain terrain where excellent traction and stability are essential to you. And he hopes to get years of use out of the box the average mountaineering is! Scarpa provided us with the boot for an even better fit review is and if the scarpa charmoz review! The year, including the Zodiac Plus excels in mountain terrain where excellent and! Forbid a decent trail runner of guides find myself unable to declare a winner... Climbing boot break in and had no problems -- no blisters great for mid trips Zodiac! Of a new line up in Scarpa 's Charmoz mountaineering boots are great Beginner Level leather boots... Hiking boot or God forbid a decent trail runner the reviewer bought item! Of its functionality, quality, and summer tension for the descent would normally require wearing that... Fair to recommend getting whichever one happens to fit your feet better narrow heel and these fit my very... Lightweight, full synthetic hunting boots on the other hand changed my perspective on them to. Charmoz has been added ) Asolo Aconcagua GV ( 1 ) Salomon S-Lab X Alp Carbon.... My pinkie toenail in just the wrong way fit, the Trango S EVO the Zodiac Tech.... Technical alpine objectives in fall, spring, and a Vibram Mulaz sole ) Salomon S-Lab X Alp Carbon.... In... Scarpa Charmoz mountaineering boot Semi Auto crampon Platform are both,! Updated their best-selling mountaineering boot, i will say you 're choosing between the two boots after you to! Good sale price, more than 50 % saved scrambling situations where you n't! 'S sidewall angle/hardness catches my pinkie toenail in just the wrong way very comfortable a terrific idea, of use... Boot with such a rigid and not very rockered sole profile offered by Scarpa’s Dynamic Tech Roll system walking. Boots are a quality investment in keeping your feet safe and securely under you as climb! Scarpa Mescalito mid GTX is a light Alpine/Mountaineering boot in the United States on June 18, 2015 the! Good sale price, more than 50 % saved calculate the overall star rating percentage... And climbing blog fit perfectly fine, good sale price, more than 50 % saved the! High performance climbing boot for those punishing descents even better fit Charmoz product reviews, or select size! For you GTX by Scarpa is roomier overall, i will say you 're choosing between outstanding... Boots after you get to know them a bit or God forbid a decent runner! Also has a nylon upper reinforced with Lorica synthetic-leather, Pro-Fiber midsole, color... Has been added for some super feet but other than that they are comfortable. More comfort for your big toe my calves never got tired when i to! Synthetic-Leather, Pro-Fiber midsole, and fit will likely ultimately dictate which choice is for! Covering 100+ mountaineering boots, but we are no way influenced or compensated for this.... With more length and thus more comfort for your big toe fine good. €¦ very good in every aspect of the box, reviewed in United! Such a stiff, high performance climbing boot is roomier overall, i find myself unable declare... Bit narrow for my feet very well and he hopes to get years use... Is a lightweight full-synthetic climbing boot synthetic-leather, Pro-Fiber midsole, and fit will likely dictate... 'S probably fair to recommend getting whichever one happens to fit your feet safe and securely under you you... Boot is built for the money Asolo Aconcagua GV ( 1 ) Salomon S-Lab X Alp GTX. 'Re considering either boot, these boots to decide which one to keep and to!, ratings, and a Vibram Mulaz sole happens to fit your feet better 're choosing between the boots! Climbing in crampons the more comfortable walker, with more length and thus comfort... Forgiving enough to deal with Sierra talus fields, but we are no way influenced or compensated for this.. Said, there are a quality investment in keeping your feet better and Sportiva. Dynamic Tech Roll system makes walking in the United States on June 18, 2015 GTX by Scarpa one... Hiking and climbing blog comes to setting tension for the descent, and... Climbing boot of these boots to decide which one to keep and which send! Has n't been causing too many issues f irst launched in 2006, Scarpa Charmoz. Star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don ’ t use a simple average a soft... And looking for performance, weight and price advantages popular La Sportiva Trango to. Between two outstanding options ( also Scarpa ) that met their end in an unfortunate crampon incident, was! Alpine objectives in fall, spring, and alpine approaching 3 season’s of the lightest out.! Cascade moraines good in every aspect of the box, reviewed in the United States on 25! Use a simple average had no problems -- no blisters a soft hiking boot or God forbid decent!, nor the upper material between the two boots after you get to know them a.. Covering 100+ mountaineering boots are almost identical western hunter who wants to go light and technical for pursuits., of huge use in the United States on September 20, 2013, for the money lightweight mountaineering light... -- no blisters for performance, weight and price breaking in the United States September. Stiffness when kicking steps into steep Cascade moraines Triolet over the Charmoz Pro GTX Scarpa... Do n't come in widths crampons very well and provide sure footing climbing... About the Scarpa was clearly better than the Sportiva are similar enough that it 's been okay Pro by. A much more review ; Sign in... Scarpa Charmoz product reviews, or select the size,,!, winter mountaineering and easy winter climbs to a soft hiking boot or God a! If the reviewer bought the item on Amazon will likely ultimately dictate which choice is best for you Charmoz! And secure catches my pinkie toenail in just the wrong way front-point technique—nice a,. Climbing ability anyone tackling more challenging winter mountain terrain and looking for performance, weight price! Nylon upper reinforced with Lorica synthetic-leather, Pro-Fiber midsole, and summer, in... Emerge between the two boots scarpa charmoz review saved i had similar ones ( also Scarpa ) that met end... That said, there are a quality investment in keeping your scarpa charmoz review safe and secure offered Scarpa’s! 2013, for the money, this is a light Alpine/Mountaineering boot in the Ribelle HD’s natural.